Meanwhile, from the other job

[kaberett]

Subject: Re: [ISOGEOCHEM] Is CaF2 safe in an EA

Thanks you all for the responses. I vaguely remember an old micro-chemical technique for mineral identification that uses powdered fluorite to produce HF, through some means, and remove silica so that the specimen can be further tested. I don’t remember the details of that technique but the idea of running CaF2 in my EA in the presence of organics did have me concerned. I’m relieved to learn that it can be done safely.

Thanks again.
-- Steve

... followed shortly afterwards by...

We used to do something like this in the lab! And we are still alive. Vogel spot test, maybe.

Fluoride + H2SO4 -> HF + .... over a burner to heat.

You do it in a test tube. Then you dip a wet glass rod into the vapours, and if it etches it, then there is fluoride.

Very cool. And QUITE safe ...

Hil

Comments

[alexseanchai]

I know JUST enough chemistry to go AUGH NO.

[kaberett]

yes indeed!

[joshuaorrizonte]

I hope you don't mind - I asked my scientist father to read this and explain what the problem is, because I'm no scientist - and he read it and went, "What? They want to do what? Yeah, that's definitely a 'bro no'."

Oish.

(He did explain, btw, heh.)

[kaberett]

AHAHAHAHA no it is completely fine that you shared this, I am so delighted in other people sharing the D:-face.

[raze]

*laughs!* Oh, my.

[kaberett]

yeeeeeeeeeep

[vass]

I don't know chemistry, but I do read xkcd, and the what-ifs, often enough to go "HF, where have I heard about HF and safety before?", track it down, and oh look it's your userpic!

"Very cool. And QUITE safe ..."

...if you don't need fingers. Or lungs. Or a lab. D:

[kaberett]

ahahahahaha quite

Of course "And QUITE safe ..." is said with the arch lift of the eyebrows and a certain wryness, but nonetheless.

[inoru_no_hoshi]

I get the feeling this ends in explosions and/or deadly gas leaks...

[kaberett]

mmhmmmmmmmmmm >>;

[exor674]

As long as it doesn't end in hypergolic ignition of test engineers and/or chemists...

[redbird]

On the off chance that you haven't already come across it, Sand Won't Save You This Time.

[kaberett]

Even though I have come across it, I always cackle with delight when reminded, so thank you :-)