kaberett: Malachite structure strongly resembling cock & balls (geococks)
I saw this with friends at the Regent Street Cinema as a National Theatre Live screening.

There was a lot I loved: it was immersive, it was absorbing, it was thrilling; the staging was creative and dynamic; I clapped at several points; I laughed out loud at many more, as did the rest of the audience.

But even as I enjoyed it in the moment, the overall experience left me feeling a little sour and a little disappointed. I don't think I can recommend it without some major caveats, and I won't be seeking out a recording, despite having been seriously considering it by the interval.

Content notes for rape/sexual assault/dubious consent, The Patriarchy Hurts Men Too, Posh White Person Talks About Race And Class, heteronormativity, sizeism.

Read more... )
kaberett: Photo of a pile of old leather-bound books. (books)
Dear everyone who has ever recommended Sheri S Tepper to me: please don't ever do so again.

I have been pointed at a pretty damning review [SO MANY TRIGGER WARNING, see below], of which the best part is:
On top of all this, the sea level is rising rapidly - oh , not because of the icecaps melting for anthropogenic reasons, that happened already and wasn't so serious. This time, it's because ice comets which were trapped deep inside the Earth when it was still forming are melting and the water is seeping upwards, raising the sea levels to a point where only tall mountains will survive.


When I say "the best part", I mean the rest of it discusses paedophilia, cultural appropriation, ~fantasy-Asia~ and talking. rapist. horses. If you can face wading through that, though, then the (well-written!) review is very much worth a read if only for the squawks of horror you will undoubtedly emit. Seriously, people, we are talking OH JOHN RINGO NO levels of dire, here.

... as someone who's been repeatedly recced stuff by Tepper on the grounds of "trans* stuff" and "queer stuff", er. Well. Yeah. Put it this way, the only book of hers I've read was kind of gross about genderfluidity and three quarters of the queer characters died, never mind the fact that it was the kind of fantasy novel that The Colour Of Magic was written to spork, in which EVERYONE IS ALREADY CARRYING EVERYONE ELSE'S QUEST ITEMS.

edit: holy shit someone in comments at that posting points out that this person seriously advocates sterilising mentally ill people and sending them to concentration camps walled cities. WOW.
kaberett: Photo of a pile of old leather-bound books. (books)
So I have finally got around to reading the Song of the Lioness quartet by Tamora Pierce - and, um, I am kind of horrified?

Like, I kept seeing it recced places because the protagonist is a woman who fights damn well, and who wants sex and who has it and who isn't shamed for it, and as far as it goes that's true, BUT.

Trans* erasure, really skeevy relationship dynamics, and racism. Lots and *lots* of racism. )


...


So now you know, and I hope never again to see an uncritical review of those books, because WOW I was not expecting any of that going in. Like, I'd be kind of fascinated to know what explanation people have for the uncritical recs apart from "BUT IT'S NOT RACIIIIIIIIIIST", but I sort of suspect there isn't one.

Profile

kaberett: Trans symbol with Swiss Army knife tools at other positions around the central circle. (Default)
kaberett

May 2025

M T W T F S S
    1 2 3 4
5 6 7 8 9 10 11
12 13 1415161718
19202122232425
262728293031 

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios